politscienceПолитическая наукаPolitical science1998-1775ИНИОН РАНpolitscience-125Research ArticleСтатьиКРИТИЧЕСКАЯ ГЕОПОЛИТИКА: ОСНОВЫ КОНЦЕПЦИИ И ОПЫТ ЕЕ ПРИМЕНЕНИЯ В РОССИИCritical geopolitics: Main concepts and field experience in RussiaКолосовВладимир Александровичvladimirkolossov@ gmail.comKolosovV. A.noemail@neicon.ruИнститут географии РАНRussian Federation20111105202304Региональное измерение политического процесса3152Copyright © Колосов В.А., Kolosov V.A., 20232023Колосов В.А., Kolosov V.A.Колосов В.А., Kolosov V.A.Данная работа распространяется под лицензией Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://www.politnauka.ru/jour/article/view/125

Кратко рассматривается эволюция основных теоретических подходов в западной геополитике, подготовившая появление в конце 1980-х - начале 1990-х годов нового междисциплинарного направления - критической геополитики. Характеризуются ее проблемaтика, категории и методы. Приводятся некоторые результаты исследований геополитического положения России, выполненные за последние 10 лет на основе концепции критической геополитики.

The author briefly considers the evolution of the main theoretical approaches in Western geopolitics which prepared the emergence in the late 1980s - the early 1990s of a new interdisciplinary field - critical geopolitics. Its main themes, categories and methods are characterized. Some results of Russia's geopolitical situation studies carried out in the last decade and using the concept of critical geopolitics are summarized.

геополитикакатегорииметодыРоссияgeopoliticscategoriesmethodsRussiaReferencesГеополитическое положение России: Представления и реальность / Под ред. В.А. Колосова. - М.: Арт-Курьер, 2001. - 348 с.Геополитическое положение России: Представления и реальность / Под ред. В.А. Колосова. - М.: Арт-Курьер, 2001. - 348 с.Колосов В.А., Тикунов В.С., Заяц Д.В. Мир в зеркале средств массовой информации: Использование анаморфоз в политико-географическом анализе // Вестник Московского университета. Сер. География. - М., 2000. - № 2. - С. 55-65.Колосов В.А., Тикунов В.С., Заяц Д.В. Мир в зеркале средств массовой информации: Использование анаморфоз в политико-географическом анализе // Вестник Московского университета. Сер. География. - М., 2000. - № 2. - С. 55-65.Колосов В.А., Туровский Р.Ф. Геополитическое положение России на пороге XXI века: Реальность и перспективы // Полис. - М., 2000. - № 3. - С. 40-60.Колосов В.А., Туровский Р.Ф. Геополитическое положение России на пороге XXI века: Реальность и перспективы // Полис. - М., 2000. - № 3. - С. 40-60.Колосов В.А., Мироненко Н.С. Геополитика и политическая география. - М.: Аспект-Пресс, 2001. - 479 c.Колосов В.А., Мироненко Н.С. Геополитика и политическая география. - М.: Аспект-Пресс, 2001. - 479 c.Геополитическая картина мира в средствах массовой информации / Колосов В.А., Бородулина Н.А., Вендина О.И., Галкина Т.А., Заяц Д.В., Юр Е.С. // Полис. - М., 2003. - № 3. - С. 33-49.Геополитическая картина мира в средствах массовой информации / Колосов В.А., Бородулина Н.А., Вендина О.И., Галкина Т.А., Заяц Д.В., Юр Е.С. // Полис. - М., 2003. - № 3. - С. 33-49.Колосов В.А., Тикунов В.С. Политико-географическое картографирование и геоинформатика: Достижения и новые задачи // Известия РАН. Сер. географическая. - М., 2005. - № 1. - C. 17-23.Колосов В.А., Тикунов В.С. Политико-географическое картографирование и геоинформатика: Достижения и новые задачи // Известия РАН. Сер. географическая. - М., 2005. - № 1. - C. 17-23.Колосов В.А. Традиционные геополитические концепции и современные вызовы России // Общественные науки и современность. - М., 1996. - № 3. - С. 13-25.Колосов В.А. Традиционные геополитические концепции и современные вызовы России // Общественные науки и современность. - М., 1996. - № 3. - С. 13-25.Мир глазами россиян: Общественное мнение и внешняя политика / Под ред. В.А. Колосова. - М.: ФОМ, 2003. - 302 с.Мир глазами россиян: Общественное мнение и внешняя политика / Под ред. В.А. Колосова. - М.: ФОМ, 2003. - 302 с.Петренко В.Ф., Митина О.В., Бердников К.А. Психосемантический анализ геополитических представлений в России // Психологический журнал. - М., 2000. - Т. 21, № 2. - С. 49-69.Петренко В.Ф., Митина О.В., Бердников К.А. Психосемантический анализ геополитических представлений в России // Психологический журнал. - М., 2000. - Т. 21, № 2. - С. 49-69.Agnew J., Corbrigde S. The new geopolitics: The dynamics of geopolitical disorder // A world in crisis: Geographical perspectives / Johnston R.J., Taylor P. (eds.). - Basil Blackwell, Oxford, 1989. - P. 266-288.Agnew J., Corbrigde S. The new geopolitics: The dynamics of geopolitical disorder // A world in crisis: Geographical perspectives / Johnston R.J., Taylor P. (eds.). - Basil Blackwell, Oxford, 1989. - P. 266-288.Archer J.C., Shelley F.M., Leib J.L. The perceived geopolitical importance of the countries of the world: An analytical and pedagogical investigation // Journal of geography. - Indiana, PA, 1997. - Vol. 96, N 1. - P. 76-83.Archer J.C., Shelley F.M., Leib J.L. The perceived geopolitical importance of the countries of the world: An analytical and pedagogical investigation // Journal of geography. - Indiana, PA, 1997. - Vol. 96, N 1. - P. 76-83.Berg E., Oras S. Writing post-Soviet Estonia on to the world map // Political geography. - Oxford, 2000. - Vol. 19. - P. 601-625.Berg E., Oras S. Writing post-Soviet Estonia on to the world map // Political geography. - Oxford, 2000. - Vol. 19. - P. 601-625.Boniface P., Védrine H. Atlas des crises et des conflits. - Paris: Armand Colin, 2009. - 117 p.Boniface P., Védrine H. Atlas des crises et des conflits. - Paris: Armand Colin, 2009. - 117 p.International trust and public opinion about world affairs / Brewer P.R., Gross K., Aday S., Wilnat L. // American journal of political science. - Hoboken, NJ, 2004. - Vol. 48, N 1. - P. 93-109.International trust and public opinion about world affairs / Brewer P.R., Gross K., Aday S., Wilnat L. // American journal of political science. - Hoboken, NJ, 2004. - Vol. 48, N 1. - P. 93-109.Brubaker R. Ethnicity without groups. - Cambridge, MA: Harvard univ. press, 2004. - 283 p.Brubaker R. Ethnicity without groups. - Cambridge, MA: Harvard univ. press, 2004. - 283 p.Brunn S., Mingst K. Geopolitics // Progress in political geography / Pacione M. (ed.). - L.: Croom Helm, 1985. - P. 41-47.Brunn S., Mingst K. Geopolitics // Progress in political geography / Pacione M. (ed.). - L.: Croom Helm, 1985. - P. 41-47.Chaliand G. Atlas stratégique. - Paris: Fayard, 1993. - 225 p.Chaliand G. Atlas stratégique. - Paris: Fayard, 1993. - 225 p.Dalby S. Creating the second cold war: The discourse of politics. - L.: Frances Pinter, 1990. - 211 p.Dalby S. Creating the second cold war: The discourse of politics. - L.: Frances Pinter, 1990. - 211 p.Dalby S., Ó Tuathail G. Rethinking geopolitics. - L.: Routledge, 1998. - 333 p.Dalby S., Ó Tuathail G. Rethinking geopolitics. - L.: Routledge, 1998. - 333 p.Reordering the world: Geopolitical perspectives on the 21st century / Demko G.J., Wood W.B. (eds.). - Boulder: Westview press, 1994. - 352 p.Reordering the world: Geopolitical perspectives on the 21st century / Demko G.J., Wood W.B. (eds.). - Boulder: Westview press, 1994. - 352 p.Dijkink G.-J. National identity and geopolitical visions: Maps of pride and pain. - L.: Routledge, 1996. - 199 p.Dijkink G.-J. National identity and geopolitical visions: Maps of pride and pain. - L.: Routledge, 1996. - 199 p.Dijkink G.-J. Geopolitical codes and popular representations // GeoJournal. - Dordrecht, 1998. - Vol. 46, N 2. - P. 293-299.Dijkink G.-J. Geopolitical codes and popular representations // GeoJournal. - Dordrecht, 1998. - Vol. 46, N 2. - P. 293-299.Dodds K. Political geography III: Critical geopolitics after ten years // Progress in human geography. - L., 2001. - Vol. 25, N 3. - P. 469-484.Dodds K. Political geography III: Critical geopolitics after ten years // Progress in human geography. - L., 2001. - Vol. 25, N 3. - P. 469-484.Dodds K. Counter-factual geopolitics: President Al Gore, September 11 and the global war on terror // Geopolitics. - L., 2008. - Vol. 13, N 1. - P. 73-99.Dodds K. Counter-factual geopolitics: President Al Gore, September 11 and the global war on terror // Geopolitics. - L., 2008. - Vol. 13, N 1. - P. 73-99.Europe in the world / Grasland C. (ed.). - Paris, 2007. - 89 p.Europe in the world / Grasland C. (ed.). - Paris, 2007. - 89 p.Iivari P. Spatial argumentation. Geopolitically featured intelligence perceptions in spatio-temporal context in Russia, 1991-2006: PhD Dissertation / Univ. of Oulu, Department of geography. - 2007. - 410 p.Iivari P. Spatial argumentation. Geopolitically featured intelligence perceptions in spatio-temporal context in Russia, 1991-2006: PhD Dissertation / Univ. of Oulu, Department of geography. - 2007. - 410 p.Kolossov V., Turovsky R. Russian geopolitics at the fin-de-siècle // Geopolitics. - L., 2001. - Vol. 6, N 1. - P. 141-164.Kolossov V., Turovsky R. Russian geopolitics at the fin-de-siècle // Geopolitics. - L., 2001. - Vol. 6, N 1. - P. 141-164.Kolossov V., Borodulina N. From Russia with love… (Russia and the West in public opinion) // Russia in global affairs. - Moscow, 2003. - Vol. 1, N 1. - P. 34-45.Kolossov V., Borodulina N. From Russia with love… (Russia and the West in public opinion) // Russia in global affairs. - Moscow, 2003. - Vol. 1, N 1. - P. 34-45.Kolossov V. "High" and "low" geopolitics: Images of foreign countries in the eyes of Russian citizens // Geopolitics. - L., 2003. - Vol. 8, N 1. - P. 121-148.Kolossov V. "High" and "low" geopolitics: Images of foreign countries in the eyes of Russian citizens // Geopolitics. - L., 2003. - Vol. 8, N 1. - P. 121-148.Kolossov V., Ó Tuathail G. An empire's fraying edge? The North Caucasus instability in contemporary Russian geopolitical culture // Eurasian geography and economics. - Columbia, MD, 2007. - Vol. 48, N 2. - P. 202-225.Kolossov V., Ó Tuathail G. An empire's fraying edge? The North Caucasus instability in contemporary Russian geopolitical culture // Eurasian geography and economics. - Columbia, MD, 2007. - Vol. 48, N 2. - P. 202-225.Kolossov V., Zotova M. Les représentations géographiques et la vision du monde en Russie: Origines et changements // Anatoli. - P., 2011. - N 6. - В печати.Kolossov V., Zotova M. Les représentations géographiques et la vision du monde en Russie: Origines et changements // Anatoli. - P., 2011. - N 6. - В печати.Light D. «Facing the future»: Tourism and identity-building in post-socialist Romania // Political geography. - Oxford, 2001. - Vol. 8, N 4. - P. 1053-1074.Light D. «Facing the future»: Tourism and identity-building in post-socialist Romania // Political geography. - Oxford, 2001. - Vol. 8, N 4. - P. 1053-1074.Mäkinen S. Russian geopolitical visions and argumentation parties of power, emocratic and communist opposition on Chechnia and NATO, 1994-2003: PhD dissertation / Univ. of Tampere, Department of political science and international relations. - 2007. - 377 p.Mäkinen S. Russian geopolitical visions and argumentation parties of power, emocratic and communist opposition on Chechnia and NATO, 1994-2003: PhD dissertation / Univ. of Tampere, Department of political science and international relations. - 2007. - 377 p.Mamadouh V.D. Geopolitics in the nineties: One flag, many meanings // Political geography. - L., 1999. - Vol.18, N 5. - P. 602-639.Mamadouh V.D. Geopolitics in the nineties: One flag, many meanings // Political geography. - L., 1999. - Vol.18, N 5. - P. 602-639.Mamadouh V.D., Dijkink G. Geopolitics, international relations and political geogrpaphy. The politics of geopolitical discourse // Geopoltics. - L., 2006. - Vol. 11, N 3. - P. 349-366.Mamadouh V.D., Dijkink G. Geopolitics, international relations and political geogrpaphy. The politics of geopolitical discourse // Geopoltics. - L., 2006. - Vol. 11, N 3. - P. 349-366.Nijman J. Madeleine Albright and the geopolitics of Europe // GeoJournal. - Dordrecht, 1998. - Vol. 46, N 4. - P. 371-382.Nijman J. Madeleine Albright and the geopolitics of Europe // GeoJournal. - Dordrecht, 1998. - Vol. 46, N 4. - P. 371-382.O'Loughlin J. Geopolitical visions of Central Europe // Europe between political geography and geopolics / M.-P. Pagnini, V. Kolossov, M. Antonsich, (eds.). - Roma: Società geografica italiana, 2001. - P. 607-625.O'Loughlin J. Geopolitical visions of Central Europe // Europe between political geography and geopolics / M.-P. Pagnini, V. Kolossov, M. Antonsich, (eds.). - Roma: Società geografica italiana, 2001. - P. 607-625.O'Loughlin J. Geopolitical fantasies and ordinary Russians: Perceptions and reality in the post-Yeltsin era // Geopolitics. - L., 2001. - Vol. 6, N 1. - P. 17-48.O'Loughlin J. Geopolitical fantasies and ordinary Russians: Perceptions and reality in the post-Yeltsin era // Geopolitics. - L., 2001. - Vol. 6, N 1. - P. 17-48.O'Loughlin J., Kolossov V. Still 'not warth the bones of a single Pomeranian grenadier: The geopolitics of the Kosovo war 1999 // Political geography. - Oxford, 2002. - Vol. 21, N 3. - P. 573-599.O'Loughlin J., Kolossov V. Still 'not warth the bones of a single Pomeranian grenadier: The geopolitics of the Kosovo war 1999 // Political geography. - Oxford, 2002. - Vol. 21, N 3. - P. 573-599.O'Loughlin J., О'Tuathail G., Kolossov V. 'A risky westward turn'? Putin's 9/11 script and ordinary Russians // Europe-Asia studies. - Abingdon, 2004a. - Vol. 56, N 1. - P. 3-34.O'Loughlin J., О'Tuathail G., Kolossov V. 'A risky westward turn'? Putin's 9/11 script and ordinary Russians // Europe-Asia studies. - Abingdon, 2004a. - Vol. 56, N 1. - P. 3-34.O'Loughlin J., О'Tuathail G., Kolossov V. Russian geopolitical storylines and ordinary Russians in the wake of 9-11 // Communist and post-communist studies. - Oxford, 2004b. - Vol. 37, N 3. - P. 281-318.O'Loughlin J., О'Tuathail G., Kolossov V. Russian geopolitical storylines and ordinary Russians in the wake of 9-11 // Communist and post-communist studies. - Oxford, 2004b. - Vol. 37, N 3. - P. 281-318.O'Loughlin J., О'Tuathail G., Kolossov V. Russian geopolitical culture in the post 9/11 era: The masks of Proteus revisited // Transactions. NS / Institute of British geographers. - L., 2005. - Vol. 30, N 3. - P. 322-335.O'Loughlin J., О'Tuathail G., Kolossov V. Russian geopolitical culture in the post 9/11 era: The masks of Proteus revisited // Transactions. NS / Institute of British geographers. - L., 2005. - Vol. 30, N 3. - P. 322-335.O'Loughlin J., О'Tuathail G., Kolossov V. The geopolitical orientations of ordinary Russians: A public opinion analysis // Eurasian geography and economics. - Columbia, MD, 2006. - Vol. 47, N 2. - P. 129-152.O'Loughlin J., О'Tuathail G., Kolossov V. The geopolitical orientations of ordinary Russians: A public opinion analysis // Eurasian geography and economics. - Columbia, MD, 2006. - Vol. 47, N 2. - P. 129-152.O'Loughlin J., Talbot P. Where in the world is Russia? Geopolitical perceptions and preferences of ordinary Russians // Eurasian geography and economics. - Columbia, MD, 2005. - Vol. 46, N 1. - P. 23-50.O'Loughlin J., Talbot P. Where in the world is Russia? Geopolitical perceptions and preferences of ordinary Russians // Eurasian geography and economics. - Columbia, MD, 2005. - Vol. 46, N 1. - P. 23-50.O'Loughlin J., Kolossov V., Ó Tuathail G. Inside Abkhazia: Survey of attitudes in a de facto state // Post-Soviet affairs. - Columbia, MD, 2011. - Vol. 27, N 1. - P. 1-36.O'Loughlin J., Kolossov V., Ó Tuathail G. Inside Abkhazia: Survey of attitudes in a de facto state // Post-Soviet affairs. - Columbia, MD, 2011. - Vol. 27, N 1. - P. 1-36.Routledge P. Critical geopolitics and terrains of resistance // Political geography. - Oxford, 1996. - Vol. 5, N 6/7. - P. 509-531.Routledge P. Critical geopolitics and terrains of resistance // Political geography. - Oxford, 1996. - Vol. 5, N 6/7. - P. 509-531.О'Tuathail G. Critical geopolitics: The politics of writing global space. - Minneapolis, MN: Univ. of Minnesota press, 1996. - 326 p.О'Tuathail G. Critical geopolitics: The politics of writing global space. - Minneapolis, MN: Univ. of Minnesota press, 1996. - 326 p.О'Tuathail G. Theorizing practical geopolitical reasoning: The case of U.S. Bosnia policy in 1992 // Political geography. - L., 2002. - Vol. 21, N 5. - P. 601-628.О'Tuathail G. Theorizing practical geopolitical reasoning: The case of U.S. Bosnia policy in 1992 // Political geography. - L., 2002. - Vol. 21, N 5. - P. 601-628.О'Tuathail G. Geopolitical structures and geopolitical cultures: Towards conceptual clarity in the critical study of geopolitics // Geopolitical perspectives on world politics / L. Tchantouridze (ed.). - Winnipeg: Centre for defence and security studies, November 2003. - Bison paper 4. - P. 75-102.О'Tuathail G. Geopolitical structures and geopolitical cultures: Towards conceptual clarity in the critical study of geopolitics // Geopolitical perspectives on world politics / L. Tchantouridze (ed.). - Winnipeg: Centre for defence and security studies, November 2003. - Bison paper 4. - P. 75-102.О'Tuathail G. Thinking critically about geopolitics // The geopolitics reader / G. О'Tuathail, S. Dalby, P. Routledge (eds.). - L.: Routledge, 2006. - 517 p.О'Tuathail G. Thinking critically about geopolitics // The geopolitics reader / G. О'Tuathail, S. Dalby, P. Routledge (eds.). - L.: Routledge, 2006. - 517 p.О'Tuathail G. Russia's Kosovo: A critical geopolitics of the August 2008 war over South Ossetia // Eurasian geography and economics. - Columbia, MD, 2008. - Vol. 49. - P. 670-705.О'Tuathail G. Russia's Kosovo: A critical geopolitics of the August 2008 war over South Ossetia // Eurasian geography and economics. - Columbia, MD, 2008. - Vol. 49. - P. 670-705.О'Tuathail G. Localizing geopolitics: Disaggregating violence and return in conflict regions // Political geography. - Oxford, 2010. - Vol. 29. - P. 256-265.О'Tuathail G. Localizing geopolitics: Disaggregating violence and return in conflict regions // Political geography. - Oxford, 2010. - Vol. 29. - P. 256-265.Sack R. Human territoriality: Its theory and history. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1986. - 272 p.Sack R. Human territoriality: Its theory and history. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1986. - 272 p.Sharp J. Condensing the cold war: Reader's digest and American identity. - L.: Routledge, 2000. - 215 p.Sharp J. Condensing the cold war: Reader's digest and American identity. - L.: Routledge, 2000. - 215 p.Smith G. The masks of Proteus: Russia, geopolitical shift, and the new eurasianism // Transactions. NS / Institute of British geographers. - L., 1999. - Vol. 24. - P. 481-500.Smith G. The masks of Proteus: Russia, geopolitical shift, and the new eurasianism // Transactions. NS / Institute of British geographers. - L., 1999. - Vol. 24. - P. 481-500.Soloviev E.G. Geopolitics in Russia - Science or vocation? // Communist and post-communist studies. - Oxford, 2004. - Vol. 37, N 1. - P. 85-96.Soloviev E.G. Geopolitics in Russia - Science or vocation? // Communist and post-communist studies. - Oxford, 2004. - Vol. 37, N 1. - P. 85-96.Taylor P.J., O'Loughlin J. Editorial essay: Political geography - research agendas for the nineteen eighties // Political geography quarterly. - Borough Green, Sevenoaks, Kent, England, 1982. - Vol. 1, N 1. - P. 1-17.Taylor P.J., O'Loughlin J. Editorial essay: Political geography - research agendas for the nineteen eighties // Political geography quarterly. - Borough Green, Sevenoaks, Kent, England, 1982. - Vol. 1, N 1. - P. 1-17.Tsygankov A.P. Rediscovering national interests after the «end of history»: Fukuyama, Russian intellectuals, and a post-Cold War order // International politics. - Athens, 2002. - Vol. 39, N 4. - P. 153-173.Tsygankov A.P. Rediscovering national interests after the «end of history»: Fukuyama, Russian intellectuals, and a post-Cold War order // International politics. - Athens, 2002. - Vol. 39, N 4. - P. 153-173.Tsygankov A.P. Mastering space in Eurasia. Russia's geopolitical thinking after the Soviet break-up // Communist and post-communist studies. - Oxford, 2003. - Vol. 35, N 1. - P. 101-127.Tsygankov A.P. Mastering space in Eurasia. Russia's geopolitical thinking after the Soviet break-up // Communist and post-communist studies. - Oxford, 2003. - Vol. 35, N 1. - P. 101-127.Tsygankov A.P. Whose world order? Russian geopolitical thinking after the Cold War. - South Bend, IN: Univ. of Notre Dame press, 2004. - 245 p.Tsygankov A.P. Whose world order? Russian geopolitical thinking after the Cold War. - South Bend, IN: Univ. of Notre Dame press, 2004. - 245 p.

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.