politscienceПолитическая наукаPolitical science1998-1775ИНИОН РАНpolitscience-149Research ArticleСтатьиПолитическая наука и современные исследования российской политики: перемены и вызовыPolitical science and contemporary research on Russian politics: Changes and challengesГельманВладимир Яковлевичgelman@eu.spb.ruGel'manV. Ja.noemail@neicon.ruЕвропейский университет в Санкт-ПетербургеRussian Federation20121105202301Два десятилетия трансформации современной российской политики823Copyright © Гельман В.Я., Gel'man V.J., 20232023Гельман В.Я., Gel'man V.J.Гельман В.Я., Gel'man V.J.Данная работа распространяется под лицензией Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://www.politnauka.ru/jour/article/view/149

В статье представлен обзор основных тенденций в исследованиях российской политики в западной политической науке после распада СССР. Ее задачей является поиск ответов на вопросы о том, как можно оценить основные достижения и недостатки исследований российской политики за последние два десятилетия. В какой мере эти научные работы улучшили наше понимание современной политики в России, каковы основные подходы к ее изучению и какие проблемы нуждаются в более углубленном анализе?

The article presents an overview of key trends of research on Russian politics in Western political science after the Soviet collapse. It is focused on analysis of major achievements and shortcomings in academic studies on Russian politics over the last two decades. To what extent this scholarship improves our understanding of contemporary political developments in Russia, what are the major frameworks for analyses, and which political issues needs more in-depth research in the future?

политологические исследованиязападная политическая наукаРоссияpolitical scienceWestern political studiesRussiaReferencesAlmond G. A discipline divided: Schools and sects in political science. - L.: Sage, 1990. - 352 p.Almond G. A discipline divided: Schools and sects in political science. - L.: Sage, 1990. - 352 p.Bates R. Area studies and the discipline: A useful controversy? // PS: Political science and politics. - Wash., 1997. - Vol. 30, N 2. - P. 166-169.Bates R. Area studies and the discipline: A useful controversy? // PS: Political science and politics. - Wash., 1997. - Vol. 30, N 2. - P. 166-169.Between dictatorship and democracy: Russia's post-communist political reform / McFaul M., Petrov N., Ryabov A. (eds.). - Wash.: Carnegie endowment for international peace, 2004. - 364 p.Between dictatorship and democracy: Russia's post-communist political reform / McFaul M., Petrov N., Ryabov A. (eds.). - Wash.: Carnegie endowment for international peace, 2004. - 364 p.Breslauer G. In defense of sovietology // Post-Soviet affairs. - Guilford, 1992. - Vol. 8, N 3. - P. 197-238.Breslauer G. In defense of sovietology // Post-Soviet affairs. - Guilford, 1992. - Vol. 8, N 3. - P. 197-238.Colton T. Yeltsin: A life. - N.Y.: Basic books, 2008. - 640 p.Colton T. Yeltsin: A life. - N.Y.: Basic books, 2008. - 640 p.Ekiert G., Kubik J., Vachudova M.A. Democracy in the post-communist world: An unending quest? // East European politics and societies. - Thousand Oaks, 2007. - Vol. 27, N 1. - P. 7-30.Ekiert G., Kubik J., Vachudova M.A. Democracy in the post-communist world: An unending quest? // East European politics and societies. - Thousand Oaks, 2007. - Vol. 27, N 1. - P. 7-30.Engerman D. Know your enemy: The rise and fall of America's soviet experts. - Oxford: Oxford univ. press, 2009. - 480 p.Engerman D. Know your enemy: The rise and fall of America's soviet experts. - Oxford: Oxford univ. press, 2009. - 480 p.Fish M.S. Democracy derailed in Russia: The failure of open politics. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2005. - 334 p.Fish M.S. Democracy derailed in Russia: The failure of open politics. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2005. - 334 p.Fish M.S. Democracy from scratch: Opposition and regime in the new Russian revolution. - Princeton: Princeton univ. press, 1995. - 312 p.Fish M.S. Democracy from scratch: Opposition and regime in the new Russian revolution. - Princeton: Princeton univ. press, 1995. - 312 p.Gehlbach S., Sonin K., Zhuravskaya E. Businessman candidates // Amer. j. of political science. - N.Y., 2010 - Vol. 54, N 3. - P. 718-736.Gehlbach S., Sonin K., Zhuravskaya E. Businessman candidates // Amer. j. of political science. - N.Y., 2010 - Vol. 54, N 3. - P. 718-736.Gel'man V. Subversive institutions and informal governance in contemporary Russia // International handbook on informal governance / T. Christiansen, C. Newhold (eds.). - Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2012. - P. 135-153.Gel'man V. Subversive institutions and informal governance in contemporary Russia // International handbook on informal governance / T. Christiansen, C. Newhold (eds.). - Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2012. - P. 135-153.Gel'man V., Ryzhenkov S. Local regimes, sub-national governance, and the «Power vertical» in contemporary Russia // Europe-Asia studies. - Abingdon, 2011. - Vol. 63, N 3. - P. 449-465.Gel'man V., Ryzhenkov S. Local regimes, sub-national governance, and the «Power vertical» in contemporary Russia // Europe-Asia studies. - Abingdon, 2011. - Vol. 63, N 3. - P. 449-465.Golosov G.V. Political parties in the regions of Russia: Democracy unclaimed. - Boulder: Lynne Rienner, 2004. - 305 p.Golosov G.V. Political parties in the regions of Russia: Democracy unclaimed. - Boulder: Lynne Rienner, 2004. - 305 p.Goode P. Redefining Russia: Hybrid regimes, fieldwork, and Russian politics // Perspectives on politics - Wash., 2010. - Vol. 8, N 4 - P. 1055-1075.Goode P. Redefining Russia: Hybrid regimes, fieldwork, and Russian politics // Perspectives on politics - Wash., 2010. - Vol. 8, N 4 - P. 1055-1075.Gorenburg D. Minority ethnic mobilization in the Russian Federation. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2003. - 312 p.Gorenburg D. Minority ethnic mobilization in the Russian Federation. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2003. - 312 p.Hale H. Why not parties in Russia? Democracy, federalism, and the state. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2006. - 275 p.Hale H. Why not parties in Russia? Democracy, federalism, and the state. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2006. - 275 p.Hanson S. Post-imperial democracies: Ideology and party formation in Third Republic France, Weimar Germany and post-soviet Russia. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2010. - 274 p.Hanson S. Post-imperial democracies: Ideology and party formation in Third Republic France, Weimar Germany and post-soviet Russia. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2010. - 274 p.Huntington S., Brzezinski Z. Political power: USA/USSR. - N.Y.: Viking press, 1964. - 461 p.Huntington S., Brzezinski Z. Political power: USA/USSR. - N.Y.: Viking press, 1964. - 461 p.Huskey E. Elite recruitment and state-society relations in technocratic authoritarian regime: The Russian case // Communist and post-communist studies. - San Francisco, 2010 - Vol. 43, N 4. - P. 363-372.Huskey E. Elite recruitment and state-society relations in technocratic authoritarian regime: The Russian case // Communist and post-communist studies. - San Francisco, 2010 - Vol. 43, N 4. - P. 363-372.Inkeles A., Bauer R. The Soviet citizen: A Daily life in totalitarian society. - Cambridge (MA): Harvard univ. press, 1959. - 533 p.Inkeles A., Bauer R. The Soviet citizen: A Daily life in totalitarian society. - Cambridge (MA): Harvard univ. press, 1959. - 533 p.Laitin D. Post-soviet politics // Annual rev. of political science. - Palo Alto, 2000. - Vol. 3. - P. 117-148.Laitin D. Post-soviet politics // Annual rev. of political science. - Palo Alto, 2000. - Vol. 3. - P. 117-148.McFaul M. Russia's unfinished revolution: Political change from Gorbachev to Putin. - Ithaca: Cornell univ. press, 2001. - XV, 400 p.McFaul M. Russia's unfinished revolution: Political change from Gorbachev to Putin. - Ithaca: Cornell univ. press, 2001. - XV, 400 p.Mebane W., Kalinin K. Electoral fraud in Russia: Vote counts analysis using second-digit test: Paper for presentation at the Annual meeting of the Midwest Political science association. - Chicago, 2010. - Mode of access: http://www-personal.umich.edu/~ wmebane/mw10B.pdf (Дата посещения: 17.10.2011.)Mebane W., Kalinin K. Electoral fraud in Russia: Vote counts analysis using second-digit test: Paper for presentation at the Annual meeting of the Midwest Political science association. - Chicago, 2010. - Mode of access: http://www-personal.umich.edu/~ wmebane/mw10B.pdf (Дата посещения: 17.10.2011.)Moore B. Social origins of dictatorship and democracy: Lords and peasants in the making of the modern world. - Boston: Beacon press, 1966. - 592 p.Moore B. Social origins of dictatorship and democracy: Lords and peasants in the making of the modern world. - Boston: Beacon press, 1966. - 592 p.Myagkov M., Ordeshook P., Shakin D. The forensics of election fraud: Russia and Ukraine. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2009. - 289 p.Myagkov M., Ordeshook P., Shakin D. The forensics of election fraud: Russia and Ukraine. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2009. - 289 p.Ostrow J., Satarov G., Khakamada I. The consolidation of dictatorship in Russia: An inside view of the demise of democracy. - N.Y.: Praeger, 2008. - 184 p.Ostrow J., Satarov G., Khakamada I. The consolidation of dictatorship in Russia: An inside view of the demise of democracy. - N.Y.: Praeger, 2008. - 184 p.Petrov N., Lipman M., Hale H. Overmanaged democracy in Russia: Governance implications of hybrid regimes. - Wash., 2010. - (Carnegie papers; N 106). - 44 р.Petrov N., Lipman M., Hale H. Overmanaged democracy in Russia: Governance implications of hybrid regimes. - Wash., 2010. - (Carnegie papers; N 106). - 44 р.Pipes R. Flight from freedom: What Russians think and want // Foreign affairs. - N.Y., 2004. - Vol. 83, N 3. - P. 9-15.Pipes R. Flight from freedom: What Russians think and want // Foreign affairs. - N.Y., 2004. - Vol. 83, N 3. - P. 9-15.Politics, work and daily life in the USSR: A survey of former Soviet citizens / Ed. by Millar J. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1987. - 440 p.Politics, work and daily life in the USSR: A survey of former Soviet citizens / Ed. by Millar J. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1987. - 440 p.Przeworski A. Democracy and the market: Political and economic reforms in Eastern Europe and Latin America. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1991. - 228 p.Przeworski A. Democracy and the market: Political and economic reforms in Eastern Europe and Latin America. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1991. - 228 p.Reuter O.J., Remington T. Dominant party regimes and the commitment problem: The case of united Russia // Comparative political studies. - Thousand Oaks, 2009. - Vol. 42, N 4. - P. 501-526.Reuter O.J., Remington T. Dominant party regimes and the commitment problem: The case of united Russia // Comparative political studies. - Thousand Oaks, 2009. - Vol. 42, N 4. - P. 501-526.Robertson G. Strikes and labor organizations in hybrid regimes // Amer. political science rev. - Wash., 2007 - Vol. 101, N 4. - P. 781-798.Robertson G. Strikes and labor organizations in hybrid regimes // Amer. political science rev. - Wash., 2007 - Vol. 101, N 4. - P. 781-798.Rutland P. Sovietology: Notes for a post-mortem // National interest. - Wash., 1993. - Vol. 31, N 3. - P. 109-122.Rutland P. Sovietology: Notes for a post-mortem // National interest. - Wash., 1993. - Vol. 31, N 3. - P. 109-122.Sakwa R. Putin: Russia's choice. - L.: Routledge, 2004. - 400 p.Sakwa R. Putin: Russia's choice. - L.: Routledge, 2004. - 400 p.Sakwa R. The crisis of Russian democracy: The dual state, factionalism, and the Medvedev succession. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2011. - 418 p.Sakwa R. The crisis of Russian democracy: The dual state, factionalism, and the Medvedev succession. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 2011. - 418 p.Schedler A. Electoral authoritarianism: The dynamics of unfree competition. - Boulder: Lynne Rienner, 2006. - 267 p.Schedler A. Electoral authoritarianism: The dynamics of unfree competition. - Boulder: Lynne Rienner, 2006. - 267 p.Sharafutdinova G. The political consequences of crony capitalism inside Russia. - Notre Dame: Univ. of Notre Dame press, 2011. - 296 p.Sharafutdinova G. The political consequences of crony capitalism inside Russia. - Notre Dame: Univ. of Notre Dame press, 2011. - 296 p.Shevtsova L. Putin's Russia. - Wash.: Carnegie endowment for international peace, 2007. - 457 p.Shevtsova L. Putin's Russia. - Wash.: Carnegie endowment for international peace, 2007. - 457 p.Shevtsova L. Yeltsin's Russia: Myths and reality. - Wash.: Carnegie endowment for international peace, 1999. - 346 p.Shevtsova L. Yeltsin's Russia: Myths and reality. - Wash.: Carnegie endowment for international peace, 1999. - 346 p.Shleifer A., Treisman D. A normal country // Foreign affairs. - N.Y., 2004. - Vol. 83, N 2. - P. 20-38.Shleifer A., Treisman D. A normal country // Foreign affairs. - N.Y., 2004. - Vol. 83, N 2. - P. 20-38.Skocpol T. States and social revolutions: A comparative analysis of France, Russia and China. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1979. - 448 p.Skocpol T. States and social revolutions: A comparative analysis of France, Russia and China. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1979. - 448 p.Stoner-Weiss K. Russia: Authoritarianism without authority // J. of democracy. - Wash., 2006. - Vol. 17, N 1. - P. 104-118.Stoner-Weiss K. Russia: Authoritarianism without authority // J. of democracy. - Wash., 2006. - Vol. 17, N 1. - P. 104-118.The politics of sub-national authoritarianism in Russia / Ed. by Gel'man V., Ross C. - Farnham: Ashgate, 2010. - 226 p.The politics of sub-national authoritarianism in Russia / Ed. by Gel'man V., Ross C. - Farnham: Ashgate, 2010. - 226 p.Urban M., Igrunov V., Mitrokhin S. The rebirth of politics in Russia. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1997. - 444 p.Urban M., Igrunov V., Mitrokhin S. The rebirth of politics in Russia. - Cambridge: Cambridge univ. press, 1997. - 444 p.Volkov V. Standard Oil and Yukos in the context of early capitalism in the United States and Russia // Demokratizatsiya: The j. of post-soviet democratization. - Wash., 2008 - Vol. 16, N 3. - P. 240-264.Volkov V. Standard Oil and Yukos in the context of early capitalism in the United States and Russia // Demokratizatsiya: The j. of post-soviet democratization. - Wash., 2008 - Vol. 16, N 3. - P. 240-264.Volkov V. Violent entrepreneurs: The use of force in the making of Russian capitalism. - Ithaca: Cornell univ. press, 2002. - 224 p.Volkov V. Violent entrepreneurs: The use of force in the making of Russian capitalism. - Ithaca: Cornell univ. press, 2002. - 224 p.Way L. The new authoritarianism in the former Soviet Union // Communist and post-communist studies. - San Francisco, 2010. - Vol. 43, N 4. - P. 335-337.Way L. The new authoritarianism in the former Soviet Union // Communist and post-communist studies. - San Francisco, 2010. - Vol. 43, N 4. - P. 335-337.White S., Kryshtanovskaya O. The sovietization of Russian politics // Post-soviet affairs. - Guilford, 2009. - Vol. 25, N 4. - P. 283-309.White S., Kryshtanovskaya O. The sovietization of Russian politics // Post-soviet affairs. - Guilford, 2009. - Vol. 25, N 4. - P. 283-309.Wilson A. Virtual politics: Faking democracy in the post-soviet world. - New Haven: Yale univ. press, 2005. - 336 p.Wilson A. Virtual politics: Faking democracy in the post-soviet world. - New Haven: Yale univ. press, 2005. - 336 p.

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.