politscienceПолитическая наукаPolitical science1998-1775ИНИОН РАНpolitscience-448Research ArticleИДЕИ И ПРАКТИКАКонцепт «другого» в исследованиях идентичности: Анализ современных дискуссийThe concept of «other» in the studies of an identity: The analysis of contemporary discussionsМалиноваОльга ЮрьевнаMalinovaO. .omalinova@mail.ruИНИОН РАН; НИУ ВШЭ; МГИМО (У) МИД РоссииРоссия20151105202304Сравнительные исследования мировой политики154169Copyright © Малинова О.Ю., 20232023Малинова О.Ю.Malinova O...This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://www.politnauka.ru/jour/article/view/448

В статье суммируются предварительные итоги дискуссий 2000-2010-х годов о феномене «другого» и связке «я» - «другой» в литературе по исследованиям международных отношений и мировой политики. Особое внимание уделяется инвентаризации аналитического инструментария эмпирических исследований феномена «друговости» - моделей, шкал и классифицирующих схем, позволяющих выделять разные модальностей формирования идентичности и диалогического включения / исключения. В заключение автор намечает круг вопросов, нуждающихся в дополнительном эмпирическом исследовании и теоретическом осмыслении.

The article summarizes preliminary results of the discussions about «the Other» and the nexus «Self / Other» in the studies of international relations and world politics in the 2000-2010 s. It is particularly focused at analysis of the research tools for comparative empirical study of othering in different concepts - models, scales and classificatory schemes that could help to reveal different modalities of inclusion / exclusion and othering in the process of identity construction. In conclusion the author suggests the range of issues for further empirical study and theoretical reflection.

концепт «другого»противопоставление «другому»(со) отношение с «другим»идентичностьметодология исследований идентичностисравнительные исследованияthe concept of «the other»otheringidentityme- thodology of identity studiescomparative studiesReferencesКрестинина Е.С. Образ «другого» в структуре современной идентичности российского общества // Полис. Политические исследования. - М., 2011. - № 4. - С. 117-124.Крестинина Е.С. Образ «другого» в структуре современной идентичности российского общества // Полис. Политические исследования. - М., 2011. - № 4. - С. 117-124.Морозов В. Россия & Другие: Идентичность и границы политического сообщества. - М.: Новое литературное обозрение, 2009. - 656 с.Морозов В. Россия & Другие: Идентичность и границы политического сообщества. - М.: Новое литературное обозрение, 2009. - 656 с.Нойманн И. Использование «Другого». Образы Востока в формировании европейских идентичностей. - М.: Новое издательство, 2004. - 336 с.Нойманн И. Использование «Другого». Образы Востока в формировании европейских идентичностей. - М.: Новое издательство, 2004. - 336 с.Попова О.В. Образ «Другого» // Политическая идентичность и политика идентичности. - М.: РОССПЭН, 2011. - Т. 1: Идентичность как категория политической науки: Словарь терминов и понятий / Отв. ред. И.С. Семененко. - С. 190-193.Попова О.В. Образ «Другого» // Политическая идентичность и политика идентичности. - М.: РОССПЭН, 2011. - Т. 1: Идентичность как категория политической науки: Словарь терминов и понятий / Отв. ред. И.С. Семененко. - С. 190-193.Abizadeh A. Does collective identity presuppose an other? On the alleged incoherence of global solidarity // American political science review. - Cambridge, MA, 2005. - Vol. 99, N 1. - P. 45-60.Abizadeh A. Does collective identity presuppose an other? On the alleged incoherence of global solidarity // American political science review. - Cambridge, MA, 2005. - Vol. 99, N 1. - P. 45-60.Berenskoetter F. Friends, there are no friends? An intimate reframing of the international // Millennium: journal of international studies. - L., etc., 2007. - Vol. 35, N 3. - P. 647-676.Berenskoetter F. Friends, there are no friends? An intimate reframing of the international // Millennium: journal of international studies. - L., etc., 2007. - Vol. 35, N 3. - P. 647-676.Brown J.D.J. A stereotype, wrapped in a cliché, inside a caricature: Russian foreign holicy and orientalism // Politics. - Chichester, etc., 2010. - Vol. 30, N 3. - P. 149-159.Brown J.D.J. A stereotype, wrapped in a cliché, inside a caricature: Russian foreign holicy and orientalism // Politics. - Chichester, etc., 2010. - Vol. 30, N 3. - P. 149-159.Bukh A. Identity, foreign policy and the ‘other’: Japan’s ‘Russia’ // European journal of international relations. - L., 2009. - Vol. 15, N 2. - P. 319-345.Bukh A. Identity, foreign policy and the ‘other’: Japan’s ‘Russia’ // European journal of international relations. - L., 2009. - Vol. 15, N 2. - P. 319-345.Campbell D. Writing security. United States foreign policy and the politics of identity. - Manchester: Manchester univ. press, 1992. - ix, 269 p.Campbell D. Writing security. United States foreign policy and the politics of identity. - Manchester: Manchester univ. press, 1992. - ix, 269 p.Casula P. «Primacy of your face»: changing discourses of national identity and national interest in the United States and Russia after the cold war // Ab imperio. - Kazan, 2010. - N 3. - P. 245-271.Casula P. «Primacy of your face»: changing discourses of national identity and national interest in the United States and Russia after the cold war // Ab imperio. - Kazan, 2010. - N 3. - P. 245-271.Clunan A.L. The social construction of Russia's resurgence. Aspirations, identity, and security interests. - Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins univ. press, 2009. - 317 p.Clunan A.L. The social construction of Russia's resurgence. Aspirations, identity, and security interests. - Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins univ. press, 2009. - 317 p.English R.D. Russia and the Idea of the West. Gorbachev, intellectuals, and the end of the Cold War. - N.Y.: Columbia univ. press, 2000. - xii, 401 p.English R.D. Russia and the Idea of the West. Gorbachev, intellectuals, and the end of the Cold War. - N.Y.: Columbia univ. press, 2000. - xii, 401 p.Ethnic groups and boundaries. The social organization of cultural differences / Ed. by F. Barth. - L.: Allen&Unwin, 1969. - 153 p.Ethnic groups and boundaries. The social organization of cultural differences / Ed. by F. Barth. - L.: Allen&Unwin, 1969. - 153 p.Grammars of identity/alterity: A structural approach / ed. by G. Baumann, A. Gingrich. - N/Y.: Berghahn books, 2004. - xv, 219 p.Grammars of identity/alterity: A structural approach / ed. by G. Baumann, A. Gingrich. - N/Y.: Berghahn books, 2004. - xv, 219 p.Godzimirski J.M. Putin and post-Soviet identity. Building blocks and buzz words // Problems of post-communism. - L., 2008. - Vol. 55, N 5. - P. 14-27.Godzimirski J.M. Putin and post-Soviet identity. Building blocks and buzz words // Problems of post-communism. - L., 2008. - Vol. 55, N 5. - P. 14-27.Hansen L. Security as practice: Discourse analysis and the Bosnian war. - L.: Routledge, 2006. - 259 p.Hansen L. Security as practice: Discourse analysis and the Bosnian war. - L.: Routledge, 2006. - 259 p.Herman, R.G. Identity, norms, and national security: the Soviet foreign policy revolution and the end of the cold war // The culture of national security: Norms and identity in world politics. - N.Y.: Columbia univ. press, 1996. - P. 271-316.Herman, R.G. Identity, norms, and national security: the Soviet foreign policy revolution and the end of the cold war // The culture of national security: Norms and identity in world politics. - N.Y.: Columbia univ. press, 1996. - P. 271-316.Hopf T. Social construction of international politics: Identities and foreign policies, Moscow, 1955 and 1999. - Ithaca: Cornell univ. press, 2002. - xvi, 299 p.Hopf T. Social construction of international politics: Identities and foreign policies, Moscow, 1955 and 1999. - Ithaca: Cornell univ. press, 2002. - xvi, 299 p.Johnson C., Coleman A. The internal other: exploring the dialectical relationship between regional exclusion and the construction of national identity // Annals of the association of American geographers. - N.Y., 2012. - Vol. 102, N 4. - P. 863-880.Johnson C., Coleman A. The internal other: exploring the dialectical relationship between regional exclusion and the construction of national identity // Annals of the association of American geographers. - N.Y., 2012. - Vol. 102, N 4. - P. 863-880.Kuus M. Europe's eastern expansion and the reinscription of otherness in East-Central Europe // Progress in human geography. - L., 2004. - Vol. 28, N 4. - P. 472-489.Kuus M. Europe's eastern expansion and the reinscription of otherness in East-Central Europe // Progress in human geography. - L., 2004. - Vol. 28, N 4. - P. 472-489.McDonagh K. ‘Talking the talk or walking the walk’: Understanding the EU’s security identity // Journal of common market studies. - Oxford, 2015. - Vol. 53, N 3 - P. 627-641.McDonagh K. ‘Talking the talk or walking the walk’: Understanding the EU’s security identity // Journal of common market studies. - Oxford, 2015. - Vol. 53, N 3 - P. 627-641.Morozov V., Rumelili B. The external constitution of European identity: Russia and Turkey as Europe-makers // Cooperation and conflict. - L., 2012. - Vol. 47, N 1. - P. 28-48.Morozov V., Rumelili B. The external constitution of European identity: Russia and Turkey as Europe-makers // Cooperation and conflict. - L., 2012. - Vol. 47, N 1. - P. 28-48.Nayak M.V., Malone Ch. American orientalism and American exceptionalism: A critical rethinking of US hegemony // International studies review. - L., 2009. - Vol. 11. - P. 253-276.Nayak M.V., Malone Ch. American orientalism and American exceptionalism: A critical rethinking of US hegemony // International studies review. - L., 2009. - Vol. 11. - P. 253-276.Neumann I.B. Uses of the other. “The East” in European identity formation. - Manchester: Manchester univ. press, 1999. - xv, 281 p.Neumann I.B. Uses of the other. “The East” in European identity formation. - Manchester: Manchester univ. press, 1999. - xv, 281 p.Norton A. Reflections on political identity. - Baltimore, MD.: The John Hopkins univ., 1993. - viii, 209 p.Norton A. Reflections on political identity. - Baltimore, MD.: The John Hopkins univ., 1993. - viii, 209 p.Petersoo P. Reconsidering otherness: constructing Estonian identity // Nations and nationalism. - Oxford, 2007. - Vol. 13, N 1. - P. 117-133.Petersoo P. Reconsidering otherness: constructing Estonian identity // Nations and nationalism. - Oxford, 2007. - Vol. 13, N 1. - P. 117-133.Prozorov S. The other as past and present: beyond the logic of «temporal othering» in IR theory // Review of international studies. - Cambridge, 2011. - Vol. 37, N 3. - Р. 1273-1293.Prozorov S. The other as past and present: beyond the logic of «temporal othering» in IR theory // Review of international studies. - Cambridge, 2011. - Vol. 37, N 3. - Р. 1273-1293.Representations of the “other/s” in the Mediterranean world and their impact on the region / ed. by N. Kuran-Burçoğlu, S. Gilson-Miller. - Istanbul: Isis press, 2004. - 308 p.Representations of the “other/s” in the Mediterranean world and their impact on the region / ed. by N. Kuran-Burçoğlu, S. Gilson-Miller. - Istanbul: Isis press, 2004. - 308 p.Rumelili B. Constructing identity and relating to difference: Understanding the EU’s mode of differentiation // Review of international studies. - Cambridge, 2004. - Vol. 30, N 1. - P. 27-47.Rumelili B. Constructing identity and relating to difference: Understanding the EU’s mode of differentiation // Review of international studies. - Cambridge, 2004. - Vol. 30, N 1. - P. 27-47.Said E.W. Orientalism. - N.Y.: Vintage books, 1979. - xi, 394 p.Said E.W. Orientalism. - N.Y.: Vintage books, 1979. - xi, 394 p.Smith A. National identity and the idea of European unity // International affairs. - L., 1992. - Vol. 68, N 1. - P. 56-76.Smith A. National identity and the idea of European unity // International affairs. - L., 1992. - Vol. 68, N 1. - P. 56-76.Tekin B.C. Representations and othering in discourse: the construction of Turkey in the EU context. - Amsterdam: John Benjamin’s publishing company, 2010. - xi, 270 p.Tekin B.C. Representations and othering in discourse: the construction of Turkey in the EU context. - Amsterdam: John Benjamin’s publishing company, 2010. - xi, 270 p.Todorov T. The conquest of America. The question of the Other / Transl. from French by R. Howard. - N.Y.: Harper Perennial, 1992. - X, 274 p.Todorov T. The conquest of America. The question of the Other / Transl. from French by R. Howard. - N.Y.: Harper Perennial, 1992. - X, 274 p.Triandafyllidou A. National identity and the ‘other’ // Ethnic and racial studies. - L., 1998. - Vol. 21, N 4. - Р. 593-612.Triandafyllidou A. National identity and the ‘other’ // Ethnic and racial studies. - L., 1998. - Vol. 21, N 4. - Р. 593-612.Waever O. European security identities // Journal of common market studies. - Oxford, 1996. - Vol. 34, N 1. - P. 103-132.Waever O. European security identities // Journal of common market studies. - Oxford, 1996. - Vol. 34, N 1. - P. 103-132.

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.