politscienceПолитическая наукаPolitical science1998-1775ИНИОН РАНpolitscience-504Research ArticleСОСТОЯНИЕ ДИСЦИПЛИНЫЭффективность государства: Новые подходыState effectiveness: New approachesЮрескулЕгор АнатольевичYureskulEgoreyureskul@hse.ruНИУ ВШЭРоссияNational Research University Higher School of EconomicsRussian Federation20161205202304Государства в современном мире: Новые подходы к исследованию7492Copyright © Юрескул Е.А., 20232023Юрескул Е.А.Yureskul E.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://www.politnauka.ru/jour/article/view/504

В статье представлен анализ современных подходов к исследованию эффективности государственной власти, особое внимание уделяется двум ключевым: организационному, направленному на исследования микроуровня, и институциональному, ориентированному на межстрановые сравнения. Автор указывает на возможность синтеза данных подходов с помощью метода оболочечного анализа (Data Envelopment Analysis). Автором проводится эмпирическое исследование региональных систем здравоохранения в России и Канаде, иллюстрирующее преимущества оболочечного анализа при изучении эффективности государства.

The article deals with contemporary approaches to state effectiveness research. The author compares the advantages and drawbacks of two key approaches prevailing in the field: the organizational approach, dealing with micro-level research; and the institutional approach, aimed at state-level comparative research. There is a way to combine the advantages of these approaches when using Data Envelopment Analysis. The author conducts an empirical research into Russian and Canadian public health care systems to illustrate the advantages of using DEA when analyzing state effectiveness.

эффективность государстваоболочечный анализData Envelopment Analysisэффективность общественного сектораэффективность здравоохраненияstate effectivenessstate efficiencyData Envelopment Analysispublic sector efficiencypublic health sector efficiencyReferencesАхременко А.С. Эффективность государственных инвестиций в публичный капитал: От модели к оценке // Полис: Политические исследования. - М., 2014. - № 6. - С. 9-31.Ахременко А.С. Эффективность государственных инвестиций в публичный капитал: От модели к оценке // Полис: Политические исследования. - М., 2014. - № 6. - С. 9-31.Ахременко А.С., Локшин И.М., Юрескул Е.А. Экономический рост и выбор политического курса в авторитарных режимах: «недостающее звено» // Полития: Анализ. Хроника. Прогноз. - М., 2015. - Т. 3, № 78. - С. 50-74.Ахременко А.С., Локшин И.М., Юрескул Е.А. Экономический рост и выбор политического курса в авторитарных режимах: «недостающее звено» // Полития: Анализ. Хроника. Прогноз. - М., 2015. - Т. 3, № 78. - С. 50-74.Ахременко А.С., Юрескул Е.А. Эффективность государственного управления: Политологический и экономический подходы // Общественные науки и современность. - М., 2013. - № 1. - С. 77-88.Ахременко А.С., Юрескул Е.А. Эффективность государственного управления: Политологический и экономический подходы // Общественные науки и современность. - М., 2013. - № 1. - С. 77-88.Декларация тысячелетия Организации Объединенных Наций // The United Nations [Сайт]. - Mode of access: http://www.un.org/en/events/pastevents/millennium_summit. shtml (Дата посещения: 16.08.2016.)Декларация тысячелетия Организации Объединенных Наций // The United Nations [Сайт]. - Mode of access: http://www.un.org/en/events/pastevents/millennium_summit. shtml (Дата посещения: 16.08.2016.)Юрескул Е.А. Влияние институциональных характеристик политической системы на эффективность государственной власти // Политическая экспертиза: ПОЛИТЭКС. - М., 2013. - № 3. - С. 228-249.Юрескул Е.А. Влияние институциональных характеристик политической системы на эффективность государственной власти // Политическая экспертиза: ПОЛИТЭКС. - М., 2013. - № 3. - С. 228-249.Acemoglu D., Robinson J. Why nations fail: The Origins of power, prosperity, and poverty. - N.Y.: Crown Bus, 2012. - 546 p.Acemoglu D., Robinson J. Why nations fail: The Origins of power, prosperity, and poverty. - N.Y.: Crown Bus, 2012. - 546 p.Adsera A., Boix C., Payne M. Are you being served? Political Accountability and quality of government // The journal of law, economics and organization. - Oxford, 2003. - Vol. 19, N 2. - P. 445-490.Adsera A., Boix C., Payne M. Are you being served? Political Accountability and quality of government // The journal of law, economics and organization. - Oxford, 2003. - Vol. 19, N 2. - P. 445-490.Afonso A., Aubyn M. Non-parametric Approaches to education and health efficiency in OECD countries // Journal of applied economics. - Buenos-Aires, 2005. - Vol. 8 (2). - P. 227-246.Afonso A., Aubyn M. Non-parametric Approaches to education and health efficiency in OECD countries // Journal of applied economics. - Buenos-Aires, 2005. - Vol. 8 (2). - P. 227-246.Balaguer-Coll M.T., Prior D., Tortosa-Ausina E. Output complexity, environmental conditions, and the efficiency of municipalities // Journal of productivity analysis. - Berlin, 2012. - Vol. 39, N 3. - P. 303-324.Balaguer-Coll M.T., Prior D., Tortosa-Ausina E. Output complexity, environmental conditions, and the efficiency of municipalities // Journal of productivity analysis. - Berlin, 2012. - Vol. 39, N 3. - P. 303-324.Battese G.E., Rao D., O’Donnell C.J. A Metafrontier Production function for estimation of technical efficiencies and technology gaps for firms operating under different technologies // Journal of productivity analysis. - Berlin, 2004. - Vol. 21, N 1. - P. 91-103.Battese G.E., Rao D., O’Donnell C.J. A Metafrontier Production function for estimation of technical efficiencies and technology gaps for firms operating under different technologies // Journal of productivity analysis. - Berlin, 2004. - Vol. 21, N 1. - P. 91-103.Boyne G.A. What is public service improvement? // Public Administration. - Oxford, 2003. - Т. 81, N 2. - С. 211-227.Boyne G.A. What is public service improvement? // Public Administration. - Oxford, 2003. - Т. 81, N 2. - С. 211-227.Brewer G.A., Hupe P.L. Working both sides of the street: Bringing together policy and organizational perspectives on public service performance: Working paper Prepared for delivery at the 9 th Public Management Research Conference, Tucson, Arizona (USA), 25-27 October 2007. - 2007. - 27 p.Brewer G.A., Hupe P.L. Working both sides of the street: Bringing together policy and organizational perspectives on public service performance: Working paper Prepared for delivery at the 9 th Public Management Research Conference, Tucson, Arizona (USA), 25-27 October 2007. - 2007. - 27 p.Carter N. Learning to measure performance: The use of indicators in organizations // Public Administration. - Oxford, 1991. - Т. 69, N 1. - С. 85-101.Carter N. Learning to measure performance: The use of indicators in organizations // Public Administration. - Oxford, 1991. - Т. 69, N 1. - С. 85-101.Charnes A., Cooper W.W., Rhodes E. Measuring the efficiency of decision making units // European journal of operational research. - Amsterdam, 1978. - N 2. - P. 429-444.Charnes A., Cooper W.W., Rhodes E. Measuring the efficiency of decision making units // European journal of operational research. - Amsterdam, 1978. - N 2. - P. 429-444.Coelli T. An introduction to efficiency and productivity analysis. - N.Y.: Springer, 2005. - 349 p.Coelli T. An introduction to efficiency and productivity analysis. - N.Y.: Springer, 2005. - 349 p.Dahlberg S, Holmberg S. Democracy and bureaucracy: How their quality matters for popular satisfaction // West European politics. - L., 2014. - Vol. 37, N 3. - P. 515-537.Dahlberg S, Holmberg S. Democracy and bureaucracy: How their quality matters for popular satisfaction // West European politics. - L., 2014. - Vol. 37, N 3. - P. 515-537.Diamond L, Plattner M.F. The global divergence of democracies. - Baltimore: Johns Hopkins univ. press, 2001. - 416 p.Diamond L, Plattner M.F. The global divergence of democracies. - Baltimore: Johns Hopkins univ. press, 2001. - 416 p.Diarra G., Plane P. Assessing the World Bank’s Influence on the good governance paradigm // Oxford development studies. - Oxford, 2014. - Т. 42, N 4. - С. 473-487.Diarra G., Plane P. Assessing the World Bank’s Influence on the good governance paradigm // Oxford development studies. - Oxford, 2014. - Т. 42, N 4. - С. 473-487.Fishman R. Rethinking dimensions of democracy for empirical analysis: Authenticity, quality, depth, and consolidation // Annual review of political science. - Palo Alto, 2016. - Vol. 19. - P. 289-309.Fishman R. Rethinking dimensions of democracy for empirical analysis: Authenticity, quality, depth, and consolidation // Annual review of political science. - Palo Alto, 2016. - Vol. 19. - P. 289-309.Fukuyama F. Governance: What do we know, and how do we know it? // Annual review political science. - Palo Alto, 2016. - Vol. 19, N 6. - P. 1-17.Fukuyama F. Governance: What do we know, and how do we know it? // Annual review political science. - Palo Alto, 2016. - Vol. 19, N 6. - P. 1-17.Grindle M.S. Good enough governance revisited // Development policy review. - L., 2007. - Т. 25, N 5. - С. 553-574.Grindle M.S. Good enough governance revisited // Development policy review. - L., 2007. - Т. 25, N 5. - С. 553-574.Gupta S., Davoodi H.R., Alonso-Terme R. Does corruption affect income inequality and poverty?: International monetary fund. Working Paper. - Washington: IMF, 1998. - N 98/76. - 41 p.Gupta S., Davoodi H.R., Alonso-Terme R. Does corruption affect income inequality and poverty?: International monetary fund. Working Paper. - Washington: IMF, 1998. - N 98/76. - 41 p.Hammond C.J. Efficiency in the provision of public services: A data envelopment analysis of UK public library systems // Applied economics. - Buenos-Aires, 2002. - Vol. 34, N 5. - P. 649-657.Hammond C.J. Efficiency in the provision of public services: A data envelopment analysis of UK public library systems // Applied economics. - Buenos-Aires, 2002. - Vol. 34, N 5. - P. 649-657.Heaton H. Productivity in service organizations. - N.Y.: McGraw Hill, 1977. - 233 p.Heaton H. Productivity in service organizations. - N.Y.: McGraw Hill, 1977. - 233 p.Holmberg S., Rothstein B., Nasiritousi N. Quality of government: What you get // Annual review of political science. - Palo Alto, 2009. - Vol. 12. - P. 135-161.Holmberg S., Rothstein B., Nasiritousi N. Quality of government: What you get // Annual review of political science. - Palo Alto, 2009. - Vol. 12. - P. 135-161.Hood C. New public management // International encyclopedia of the social and behavioral sciences / N. Smelser, B. Baltes (eds). - Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2001. - Vol. 12. - P. 12553-12556.Hood C. New public management // International encyclopedia of the social and behavioral sciences / N. Smelser, B. Baltes (eds). - Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2001. - Vol. 12. - P. 12553-12556.Hooghe L., Marks G. Does efficiency shape the territorial structure of government? // Annual review of political science. - Palo Alto, 2009. - Vol. 12. - P. 225-241.Hooghe L., Marks G. Does efficiency shape the territorial structure of government? // Annual review of political science. - Palo Alto, 2009. - Vol. 12. - P. 225-241.Iftimoaei C. Toward a sociological approach of good governance // Scientific annals of the 'Al. I. Cuza' University, Iasi. Sociology & Social Work. - Iasi, 2015. - Vol. 8, Issue 1. - P. 101-119.Iftimoaei C. Toward a sociological approach of good governance // Scientific annals of the 'Al. I. Cuza' University, Iasi. Sociology & Social Work. - Iasi, 2015. - Vol. 8, Issue 1. - P. 101-119.Inklaar R., Timmer M. Capital, labor and TFP in PWT8.0. - Groningen: Univ. of Groningen, 2013. - 38 p.Inklaar R., Timmer M. Capital, labor and TFP in PWT8.0. - Groningen: Univ. of Groningen, 2013. - 38 p.Kaufmann D., Kraay A., Mastruzzi M. Measuring governance using perceptions data: International handbook on the economics of corruption / S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.). - Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar, 2006. - 615 p.Kaufmann D., Kraay A., Mastruzzi M. Measuring governance using perceptions data: International handbook on the economics of corruption / S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.). - Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar, 2006. - 615 p.Kelly R.M. Ideology, effectiveness, and public sector productivity: With illustrations from the field of higher education // Journal of social issues. - Hoboken, NJ, 1980. - Vol. 36, N 4. - P. 76-95.Kelly R.M. Ideology, effectiveness, and public sector productivity: With illustrations from the field of higher education // Journal of social issues. - Hoboken, NJ, 1980. - Vol. 36, N 4. - P. 76-95.Kervasdoué J. Rating and evaluating health systems: The value of the life expectancy approach // International public management journal. - L.: Taylor & Francis, 2008. - Vol. 11, N 3. - P. 329-343.Kervasdoué J. Rating and evaluating health systems: The value of the life expectancy approach // International public management journal. - L.: Taylor & Francis, 2008. - Vol. 11, N 3. - P. 329-343.Kurtz M.J., Schrank A. Growth and governance: A defense // Journal of politics. - Chicago, 2007. - N 69. - P. 563-569.Kurtz M.J., Schrank A. Growth and governance: A defense // Journal of politics. - Chicago, 2007. - N 69. - P. 563-569.Lee F.E. How party polarization affects governance // Annual review of political science. - Palo Alto, 2015. - Т. 18. - P. 261-282.Lee F.E. How party polarization affects governance // Annual review of political science. - Palo Alto, 2015. - Т. 18. - P. 261-282.Lopez J.H. Pro-growth, pro-poor: Is there a tradeoff?: World Bank policy research working paper. - Washington, DC, 2010. - N 3378. - 29 p.Lopez J.H. Pro-growth, pro-poor: Is there a tradeoff?: World Bank policy research working paper. - Washington, DC, 2010. - N 3378. - 29 p.Organizational assessment: A framework for improving performance / C. Lusthaus, M.H. Adrien, G. Anderson, F. Carden, G.P. Montalvan. - Ottawa: International development research center, 2002. - 139 p.Organizational assessment: A framework for improving performance / C. Lusthaus, M.H. Adrien, G. Anderson, F. Carden, G.P. Montalvan. - Ottawa: International development research center, 2002. - 139 p.North D.C., Weingast B.R., Wallis J. Violence and social orders: A conceptual framework for interpreting recorded human history. - N.Y.: Cambridge univ. press, 2009. - 346 p.North D.C., Weingast B.R., Wallis J. Violence and social orders: A conceptual framework for interpreting recorded human history. - N.Y.: Cambridge univ. press, 2009. - 346 p.North D.C. Institutions, institutional change, and economic performance. - N.Y.: Cambridge univ. press, 1990. - 159 p.North D.C. Institutions, institutional change, and economic performance. - N.Y.: Cambridge univ. press, 1990. - 159 p.Quinn D.P., Woolley J.T. Democracy and national economic performance: The preference for stability // American journal of political science. - Hoboken, NJ, 2001. - Vol. 45, N 3. - P. 634-657.Quinn D.P., Woolley J.T. Democracy and national economic performance: The preference for stability // American journal of political science. - Hoboken, NJ, 2001. - Vol. 45, N 3. - P. 634-657.Rauch J., Evans P. Bureaucratic structure and bureaucratic performance in less developed countries // Journal of public economics. - Amsterdam, 2000. - Vol. 75 (1). - P. 49-71.Rauch J., Evans P. Bureaucratic structure and bureaucratic performance in less developed countries // Journal of public economics. - Amsterdam, 2000. - Vol. 75 (1). - P. 49-71.Rothstein B., Holmberg S. The quality of government: Corruption, Social trust, and inequality in international perspective. - Chicago: Univ. Chicago press, 2011. - 304 p.Rothstein B., Holmberg S. The quality of government: Corruption, Social trust, and inequality in international perspective. - Chicago: Univ. Chicago press, 2011. - 304 p.Rothstein B., Teorell J. What is quality of government? A theory of impartial government institutions // Governance. - San Diego, 2008. - С. 165-190.Rothstein B., Teorell J. What is quality of government? A theory of impartial government institutions // Governance. - San Diego, 2008. - С. 165-190.Theories of the Policy Process / P. Sabatier (ed.). - 2 nd edition. - Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2007. - 352 p.Theories of the Policy Process / P. Sabatier (ed.). - 2 nd edition. - Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2007. - 352 p.Simar L., Wilson P. Estimation and inference in two-stage, semi-parametric models of production processes // Journal of econometrics. - Amsterdam, 2007. - N 136. - P. 31-64.Simar L., Wilson P. Estimation and inference in two-stage, semi-parametric models of production processes // Journal of econometrics. - Amsterdam, 2007. - N 136. - P. 31-64.Waheed A., Mansor N., Ismail N. Delivering better government: Assessing the effectiveness of public sector organizations // Asia-Pacific social science review. - 2011. - N 11 (1). - P. 61-78.Waheed A., Mansor N., Ismail N. Delivering better government: Assessing the effectiveness of public sector organizations // Asia-Pacific social science review. - 2011. - N 11 (1). - P. 61-78.Governance and development / World Bank. - Washington, DC: World Bank, 1992. - 69 p.Governance and development / World Bank. - Washington, DC: World Bank, 1992. - 69 p.The state in a changing world / World Bank. - Oxford: Oxford univ. press, 1997. - Mode of access: https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/5980 (Дата посещения: 16.08.2016.)The state in a changing world / World Bank. - Oxford: Oxford univ. press, 1997. - Mode of access: https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/5980 (Дата посещения: 16.08.2016.)

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.