Preview

Political science

Advanced search

Symbolic politics as a matter of political science and Russian studies: Studies of political uses of the past in post-Soviet Russia

https://doi.org/10.31249/poln/2020.02.01

Abstract

In this review article we examine political science’s contribution to post-Soviet symbolic politics through a focus on memory politics, which took center stage in the political competition among post-Communist elites. Under the Soviet regime, Communist ideology and its symbolism permeated both public and private life. After this system collapsed, confronting the ancient regime’s symbolic presence became a visible and often dramatic aspect of post-Soviet transformation in the newly independent states. This led to the proliferation of research on symbolic politics in post-Communist countries. The authors argue that political scientists, newly inspired by post-Soviet memory politics, have made two major contributions to the field of memory studies. First, political scientists brought the issue of power to the fore - who had the power to manipulate symbols in public space, and to what political ends? This research encourages a focus on the interactions among various mnemonic actors, rather than solely on the state. Second, political scientists brought innovative comparative theories and methods to a field previously dominated by studies of single monuments, cities, and countries. At the same time, the interdisciplinary nature of memory studies has encouraged political scientists to conceptualize power in more nuanced ways and helped to spread and legitimize the use of interpretive and ethnographic methods in political science.

About the Authors

J. Johnson
McGill University
Canada

Montreal



O. Yu. Malinova
National Research University Higher School of Economics; Institute of Scientific Information for Social Sciences, Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation


References

1. Копосов Н.Е. Память строгого режима. История и политика в России. М.: НЛО, 2011. 320 с. EDN: QPSCET

2. Малинова О.Ю. Символическая политика: контуры проблемного поля // Символическая политика. М.: РАН. ИНИОН, 2012. Вып. 1: Конструирование представлений о прошлом как властный ресурс. С. 5-16.

3. Малинова О.Ю. Актуальное прошлое: Символическая политика властвующей элиты и дилеммы российской идентичности. М.: Политическая энциклопедия, 2015. 190 с. EDN: UIAXZD

4. Малинова О.Ю. Коммеморация столетия революции(й) 1917 года в РФ: анализ стратегий ключевых мнемонических акторов // Полис. Политические исследования. 2018 a. № 1. С. 9-25. DOI: 10.17976/jpps/2018.01.02 EDN: YLYUEU

5. Малинова О.Ю. Коммеморация столетия революции(й) 1917 года в РФ: сравнительный анализ соперничающих нарративов // Полис. Политические исследования. 2018 b. № 2. С. 37-56. DOI: 10.17976/jpps/2018.02.04 EDN: YTZLUL

6. Миллер А.И. Историческая политика в России: новый поворот? // Историческая политика в XXI веке / под ред. А.И. Миллера, М. Липман. М.: НЛО, 2012. С. 328-367. EDN: RJNTZB

7. Мисюров Д.А. Политическая символика: между идеологией и рекламой // Полис. Политические исследования. 1999. № 1. С. 168-174. EDN: ESCQOX

8. Поцелуев С.П. Символическая политика как инсценирование и эстетизация // Полис. Политические исследования. 1999. № 5. С. 62-76. EDN: ESCRKL

9. Поцелуев С.П. "Символическая политика": к истории концепта // Символическая политика. М.: РАН. ИНИОН, 2012. Вып. 1: Конструирование представлений о прошлом как властный ресурс. С. 17-53. EDN: PJPQUJ

10. Символическая политика. М.: РАН. ИНИОН, 2012. Вып. 1: Конструирование представлений о прошлом как властный ресурс. 334 c.

11. Символическая политика. М.: РАН. ИНИОН, 2014. Вып. 2: Споры о прошлом как проектирование будущего. 382 с.

12. Символическая политика. М.: РАН. ИНИОН, 2015. Вып. 3: Политические функции мифов. 371 с.

13. Символическая политика. М.: РАН. ИНИОН, 2016. Вып. 4: Социальное конструирование пространства. 371 с.

14. Символическая политика. М.: РАН. ИНИОН, 2017. Вып. 5: Политика идентичности. 356 с.

15. Anderson B. Imagined communities: reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism. N.Y.: Verso, 1991. 256 р.

16. Art D. The politics of the Nazi Past in Germany and Austria. Cambridge: Cambridge university press, 2006. xii, 231 p.

17. Barkan E. The guilt of nations: restitution and negotiating historical injustices. N.Y.: W.W. Norton, 2000. xii, 414 p.

18. Bell J. Redefining national identity in Uzbeskistan: symbolic tensions in Tashkent's official public landscape // Cultural geographies. 1999. Vol. 6, N 2. P. 183-213. DOI: 10.1177/096746089900600204 EDN: JQUZXB

19. Biesecker B.A. Remembering World War II: the rhetoric and politics of national commemoration at the turn of the 21 st century // Quarterly journal of speech. 2002. Vol. 88, N 4. P. 393-409. DOI: 10.1080/00335630209384386

20. Bodnar J. Assembling the square: social transformation in public space and the broken mirage of the second economy in postsocialist Budapest // Slavic review. 1998. Vol. 57, N 3. P. 489-515. DOI: 10.2307/2500709 EDN: LRZJGV

21. Booth W.J. Communities of memory: On identity, memory, and debt // American political science review. 1999. Vol. 93, N 2. P. 249-263. DOI: 10.2307/2585394

22. Brysk A. "Hearts and minds": bringing symbolic politics back in" // Polity. 1995. Vol. 27, N 4. P. 559-585. DOI: 10.2307/3234960 EDN: HJXXEN

23. Brüggemann K., Kasekamp A. The politics of history and the "War of Monuments" in Estonia // Nationalities papers. 2008. Vol. 36, N 3. P. 425-448. DOI: 10.1080/00905990802080646

24. Bruter M. Winning hearts and minds for Europe: The impact of news and symbols on civic and cultural European identity // Comparative political studies. 2003. Vol. 36, N 10. P. 1148-1179. DOI: 10.1177/0010414003257609 EDN: JRCFQZ

25. Bucur M. Treznea trauma, nationalism and the memory of World War II in Romania // Rethinking history. 2002. Vol. 6, N 1. P. 35-55. DOI: 10.1080/13642520110112100

26. Cochrane A. Making up meanings in a capital city: power, memory and monuments in Berlin // European urban and regional studies. 2006. Vol. 13, N 1. P. 5-24. DOI: 10.1177/0969776406060827 EDN: JRXTZB

27. Corney F.C. Interrogating the past in modern Russia: the promise and peril of historical memory studies: guest editor's introduction // Russian studies in history. 2010. Vol. 49, N 1. P. 3-7. DOI: 10.2753/rsh1061-1983530100

28. Cruz C. Identity and persuasion: how nations remember their pasts and make their futures // World politics. 2000. Vol. 52, N 3. P. 275-312. DOI: 10.1017/s0043887100016555 EDN: HBAEVV

29. Danilova N. The Politics of war commemoration in the UK and Russia. L.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2015. xv, 256 p.

30. Danzer A.M. Battlefields of ethnic symbols. Public space and post-Soviet identity formation from a minority perspective // Europe-Asia studies. 2009. Vol. 61, N 9. P. 1557-1577. DOI: 10.1080/09668130903209137

31. Davis Cross M.K. Identity politics and European integration // Comparative politics.-2012. Vol. 44, N 2. P. 229-246. 10.5129/ 001041512798838012. DOI: 10.5129/001041512798838012

32. De Lue S.M. The enlightenment, public memory, liberalism, and the post-communist world // East European politics and societies. 2006. Vol. 20, N 3. P. 395-418. DOI: 10.1177/0888325405275985 EDN: JRPPKN

33. Dittmer L. Political culture and political symbolism: Toward a theoretical synthesis // World politics. 1977. Vol. 29, N 4. P. 552-583. DOI: 10.2307/2010039

34. Dixon J.M. Dark pasts. Changing the state's story in Turkey and Japan. Ithaca etc.: Cornell university press, 2018. xii, 258 p.

35. Edelman M. The symbolic uses of politics. Urbana: University of Illinois press, 1964. 201 p.

36. Edelman M. Politics as symbolic action. Mass arousal and quiescence. Chicago: Markham publishing company, 1971. ix, 188 p.

37. Foote K., Toth A., Arvay A. Hungary after 1989: Inscribing a new past on place.

38. Geographical Review. 2000. Vol. 90, N 3. P. 301-334. DOI: 10.2307/3250856 EDN: DKERKZ

39. Forest B., Johnson J., Till K. Post-totalitarian national identity: public memory in Germany and Russia // Social & cultural geography. 2004. Vol. 5, N 3. P. 357-380. DOI: 10.1080/1464936042000252778 EDN: LRZJWP

40. Forest B., Johnson J. Monumental politics: regime type and public memory in post-communist states // Post-Soviet affairs. 2011. Vol. 27, N 3. P. 269-288. DOI: 10.2747/1060-586x.27.3.269 EDN: ONMVEF

41. Fornäs J. Signifying Europe. Chicago: University of Chicago press, 2012. 339 p.

42. Gamson W.A., Stuart D. Media discourse as a symbolic contest: the bomb in political cartoons // Sociological Forum. 1992. Vol. 7, N 1. P. 55-86. DOI: 10.1007/bf01124756

43. Gellner E. Nations and nationalism. Ithaca: Cornell university press, 1983. 152 p.

44. Gill G. Symbols and legitimacy in Soviet politics. Cambridge: Cambridge university press, 2011. vi, 356 p. EDN: WNMWQJ

45. Gill G. Symbolism and regime change: Russia. Cambridge: Cambridge university press, 2013. viii, 246 p.

46. Goeckel R.F. The Luther anniversary in East Germany // World politics. 1984. Vol. 37, N 1. P. 112-133. DOI: 10.2307/2010308

47. Goode J.P. Redefining Russia: hybrid regimes, fieldwork, and Russian politics.

48. Perspectives on Politics. 2010. Vol. 8, N 4. P. 1055-1075. DOI: 10.1017/s153759271000318x EDN: OMARKB

49. Goode J.P. Humming along: Public and private patriotism in Putin's Russia // Everyday nationhood: Theorising culture, identity and belonging after banal nationalism / M. Skey, M. Antonsich (eds). L.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2017. P. 121-146. EDN: YEHCZF

50. Grant B. New Moscow monuments, or, states of innocence // American ethnologist. 2001. Vol. 28, N 2. P. 332-362. DOI: 10.1525/ae.2001.28.2.332 EDN: GRRBMV

51. Halbwachs M. On collective memory. Chicago: University of Chicago press, 1992. 244 p.

52. Irwin-Zarecka I. Frames of remembrance. The dynamics of collective memory. New Brunswick etc.: Transaction Publishers, 1994. xiv, 214 p.

53. James B. Fencing in the past: Budapest's statue park museum // Media Culture & Society. 1999. Vol. 21, N 3. P. 291-311. 10.1177/ 016344399021003001. DOI: 10.1177/016344399021003001 EDN: JOKGHD

54. James B. Imagining postcommunism: Visual narratives of Hungary's 1956 Revolution. Texas: A&M University press, 2005. xi, 202 p.

55. Jezernik B. Monuments in the winds of change // International journal of urban and regional research. 1998. Vol. 22, N 4. P. 582-588. DOI: 10.1111/1468-2427.00162

56. Joesalu K. The role of the Soviet past in post-Soviet memory politics through examples of speeches from Estonian presidents // Europe-Asia studies. 2012. Vol. 64, N 6. P. 1007-1032. DOI: 10.1080/09668136.2012.691723 EDN: WNLWMJ

57. Karn A. Amending the past. Europe's Holocaust commissions and the right to history. Wisconsin: The university of Wisconsin press, 2015. 336 p.

58. Kaufman S.J. Modern hatreds: The symbolic politics of ethnic war. Ithaca: Cornell university press, 2001. 401 p.

59. Kertzer D.I. Ritual, politics, and power. New Haven, etc.: Yale university press, 1988. ix, 235 p.

60. Khazanov A.M. Post-Communist Moscow: re-building the "third Rome' in the country of missed opportunities? // City & Society. 1998. Vol. 10, N 1. P. 269-314. DOI: 10.1525/city.1998.10.1.269

61. Langenbacher E. Twenty-first century memory regimes in Germany and Poland: an analysis of elite discourses and public opinion // German politics and society. 2008. Vol. 26, N 4. P. 50-81. DOI: 10.3167/gps.2008.260404

62. Langenbacher E. Collective memory as a factor in political culture and international relations // Power and the past. Collective memory and international relations / E. Langenbacher, Y. Shain (eds). Washington: Georgetown university press, 2010. P. 13-49.

63. Laruelle M. Commemorating 1917 in Russia: ambivalent state history policy and the church's conquest of the history market // Europe-Asia studies. 2019. Vol. 71, N 2. P. 249-267. DOI: 10.1080/09668136.2018.1552922 EDN: ZPBYUU

64. Lehti M., Jutila M., Jokisipilä M. Never-ending Second World War: public performances of national dignity and the drama of the Bronze soldier // Journal of Baltic studies. 2008. Vol. 39, N 4. P. 393-418. 10.1080/ 01629770802461175. DOI: 10.1080/01629770802461175 EDN: LKWIHV

65. Malinova O. The embarrassing centenary: reinterpretation of the 1917 revolution in the official historical narrative of post-soviet Russia (1991-2017) // Nationalities papers. 2018 c. Vol. 46, N 2. P. 272-289. 10.1080/ 00905992.2017.1386639. DOI: 10.1080/00905992.2017.1386639 EDN: UYGCOW

66. Maoz Z. The Pursuit of peace and the crisis of Israeli identity: defending/defining the nation // Perspectives on politics. 2008. Vol. 6, N 1. P. 211-212. DOI: 10.1017/s1537592708080559

67. Margalit A. The ethics of memory. Cambridge: Harvard university press, 2002. 240 p.

68. Merridale C. Redesigning history in contemporary Russia // Journal of contemporary history. 2003. Vol. 38, N 1. P. 13-28. 10.1177/ 0022009403038001961. DOI: 10.1177/0022009403038001961

69. Mink G., Neumayer L. Introduction // History, memory and politics in Central and.

70. Eastern Europe: memory games / G. Mink, L. Neumayer (eds). Basingstoke, etc.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013. P. 1-20.

71. Murphy A.R. Longing, nostalgia, and golden age politics: The American jeremiad and the power of the past // Perspectives on politics. 2009. Vol. 7, N 1. P. 125-141. DOI: 10.1017/s1537592709090148

72. Nelson T.H. History as ideology: The portrayal of Stalinism and the Great Patriotic War in contemporary Russian high school textbooks // Post-Soviet affairs. 2015. Vol. 31, N 1. P. 37-65. DOI: 10.1080/1060586x.2014.942542 EDN: URQWCH

73. Norris S.M. Memory for sale: Victory Day 2010 and Russian remembrance // The Soviet and post-Soviet review. 2011. Vol. 38, N 2. P. 201-229. DOI: 10.1163/187633211x589123 EDN: PKHMJL

74. Nunnally S.C. How we remember (and forget) in our public history // Perspectives on politics. 2016. Vol. 14, N 3. P. 764-765. 10.1017/ s1537592716001328. DOI: 10.1017/s1537592716001328

75. Olick J.K. "Collective memory": a memoir and prospect // Memory studies. 2008. Vol. 1, N 1. P. 23-29. DOI: 10.1177/1750698007083885

76. Olick J.K, Sierp A., Wüstenberg J. The Memory studies association: ambitions and an invitation // Memory studies. 2017. Vol. 10, N 4. P. 490-494. DOI: 10.1177/1750698017721792

77. Onken E.C. The Baltic states and Moscow's 9 May commemoration: Analysing memory politics in Europe // Europe-Asia Studies. 2007. Vol. 59, N 1. P. 23-46. DOI: 10.1080/09668130601072589 EDN: MHADWP

78. Realms of memory: rethinking the French past / P. Nora (ed.). New York: Columbia university press, 1996. Vol. 1: Conflicts and divisions. 642 p.

79. Ricœur P. Memory, history, forgetting. Chicago: University of Chicago press, 2004. 624 p.

80. Schleifman N. Moscow's Victory park: a monumental change // History and memory. 2001. Vol. 13, N 2. P. 5-34. DOI: 10.1353/ham.2001.0012

81. Sherlock T. Historical narratives in the Soviet Union and post-Soviet Russia: Destroying the settled past, creating an uncertain future. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007. viii, 271 p.

82. Segesten A.D., Wustenberg J. Memory Studies: The state of an emergent field // Memory Studies. 2017. Vol. 10, N 4. P. 474-489. 10.1177/ 1750698016655394. DOI: 10.1177/1750698016655394

83. Sidorov D. National monumentalization and the politics of scale: the resurrections of the cathedral of Christ the Savior in Moscow // Annals of the Association of American geographers. 2000. Vol. 90, N 3. P. 548-572. DOI: 10.1111/0004-5608.00208

84. Smith A. Myths and memories of the nation. Oxford: Oxford university press, 2000. 288 p.

85. Smith K.E. Remembering Stalin's victims: popular memory and the end of the USSR. Ithaca, NY: Cornell university press, 1996. 238 p.

86. Smith K.E. Mythmaking in the new Russia: politics and memory in the Yeltsin era. Ithaca: Cornell university press, 2002. xi, 223 p.

87. Smyth R., Sobolev A., Soboleva I. A Well-organized play: symbolic politics and the effect of the pro-Putin rallies // Problems of Post-Communism. 2013. Vol. 60, N 2. P. 24-39. DOI: 10.2753/ppc1075-8216600203 EDN: RFKSLX

88. Suny R. Provisional stabilities: the politics of identity in Post-Soviet Eurasia // International security. 1999-2000. Vol. 24, N 3. P. 139-178. DOI: 10.1162/016228899560266 EDN: GWVOOR

89. The art of commemoration: fifty years after the Warsaw uprising / ed. by T. Ensink, C. Sauer. Amsterdam etc.: John Benjamins publishing company, 2003. xi, 245 p.

90. The invention of tradition / E. Hobsbawm, T. Ranger (eds). Cambridge: Cambridge university press, 1983. vii, 320 p.

91. The role of ideas in political analysis. A portrait of contemporary debates / A. Gofas, C. Hay (eds). L. etc.: Routledge, 2010. 224 p.

92. Twenty years after communism: The politics of memory and commemoration / M.H. Bernhard, J. Kubik (eds). Oxford: Oxford university press, 2014. xviii, 362 p.

93. Varshney A. Nationalism, ethnic conflict, and rationality // Perspectives on politics.-politics. -2003. Vol. 1, N 1. P. 85-99. DOI: 10.1017/s1537592703000069 EDN: FOOJST

94. Verdery K. The political lives of dead bodies: reburial and postsocialist change. New York: Columbia university press, 1999. 208 p.

95. Vujačić V. Elites, narratives, and nationalist mobilization in the former Yugoslavia // Comparative politics. 2007. Vol. 40, N 1. P. 103-124. DOI: 10.5129/001041507x12911361134514

96. War and memory in Russia, Ukraine and Belarus / J. Fedor et. al. (eds). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2017. xxvii, 506 p.

97. White A. The memorial society in the Russian provinces // Europe-Asia studies. 1995. Vol. 47, N 8. P. 1343-1366. DOI: 10.1080/09668139508412324 EDN: WIPCCM

98. Wood E.A. Performing memory: Vladimir Putin and the celebration of World War II in Russia // The Soviet and Post-Soviet review. 2011. Vol. 38, N 2. P. 172-200. DOI: 10.1163/187633211x591175 EDN: PGVWKP

99. Wüstenberg J., Art D. Using the past in the Nazi successor states from 1945 to the present // The annals of the American academy of political and social science. 2008. Vol. 617. P. 72-87. DOI: 10.1177/0002716207312762 EDN: JLETTR

100. Young J. The texture of memory: Holocaust memorials and meaning. New Haven, CT: Yale university press, 1993. 398 p.

101. Booth W.J. The unforgotten: Memories of justice // American political science review. 2001. Vol. 95, N 4. P. 777-791. 10.1017/ s0003055400400018. DOI: 10.1017/s0003055400400018 EDN: FOQCVL

102. Ethington P.J., McDaniel J.A. Political places and institutional spaces: The intersection of political science and political geography // Annual Review of Political Science. 2007. Vol. 10, N 1. P. 127-142. DOI: 10.1146/annurev.polisci.10.080505.100522

103. Forest B., Johnson J. Unraveling the threads of history: Soviet-era monuments and post-Soviet national identity in Moscow // Annals of the association of American eographers. 2002. Vol. 92, N 3. P. 524-547. DOI: 10.1111/1467-8306.00303

104. Khazanov A.M. Selecting the past: the politics of memory in Moscow's history museums // City & Society. 2000. Vol. 12, N 2. P. 35-62. DOI: 10.1525/city.2000.12.2.35 EDN: TZXRBV

105. Schatz E. Transnational image making and soft authoritarian Kazakhstan // Slavic review. 2008. Vol. 67, N 1. P. 50-62. DOI: 10.2307/27652766


Review

Views: 821


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 1998-1775 (Print)